FACT-INFO.AZ » News » Alexander Murinson: For Armenia, international law is an empty notion
7-10-2015, 10:40 | News
Alexander Murinson: For Armenia, international law is an empty notion

In his article, headlined "Revisiting events in Nagorno-Karabakh, Murinson calls Nagorno-Karabakh “an unhealed wound in the very psyche of Azerbaijan”.

Emerging as a result of an interethnic war of secession in a region of the Soviet Azerbaijan during the collapse of the Soviet empire, it is one of the bloodiest conflicts in the post-Soviet space. Between 1992 and 1993, as the result of hostilities, Armenians expanded their occupation of the regions outside of the Nagorno-Karabakh proper, namely, Khojaly, Kelbajar, Agdam, Fizuli, Jabrail, Zangilan and Lachin. The internationally recognized International Crisis Group concluded that the war, in fact, created one million of refugees, who to this day exist as internally displaced persons in Azerbaijan. The conflict was "frozen" by the cease-fire agreement signed in Alma-Aty in 1994.”

“Although mutual accusations are only natural in any interethnic conflict, particularly one such as this marked by extreme violence and disproportionate use of force, what remains is the incontrovertible fact that it was the Armenian side which was the aggressor. Armenia, today, continues its illegal occupation of the territory recognized by international law as the sovereign territory of Republic of Azerbaijan.”

“U.N. Resolution 822 of April 30, 1993, "calls for the cessation of hostilities and withdrawal of local occupying forces troops (in this case, the "local occupying forces" refers to the Armenian forces-ABM) from Kelbajar district following its occupation on April 3, 1993. United Nations 853 of July 29, 1993, "demands the immediate cessation of all hostilities, calls on withdrawal of local Armenian troops from Agdam district of Azerbaijan occupied on June 23, 1993 and reaffirms U.N. Resolution 822," says Murinson.

“Enter the recent judgment in the case "Chiragov and others v. Armenia" on 16 June 2015 in the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR).

Emerging from an unexpected quarter, the European Court's ruling, the most definitive statement based on international law to date, made Armenia culpable as the aggressor and the "occupier" of Azerbaijani lands. A ruling by such an institution as the European Court of Human Rights, which cannot be suspected of favoring Azerbaijan, finally confirmed and took away any question that Armenia, in fact, is the culprit in the case of Nagorno-Karabakh occupation.

In this case, a group of former Azerbaijani residents of Lachin filed a lawsuit in the ECHR with a single goal: to return to their homes and property, after having been forced by Armenians to leave in 1992. The Court ruled: "[t]here had been violations on all accounts of the complaint (violations of several articles of the European Convention on Human Rights, on protection of property, of right to respect for private and family life, of right to an effective remedy)." But most importantly, the court's ruling dismissed several objections put forward by the government of Armenia, including the one that this country didn't have effective control over the territory of Nagorno-Karabakh and the surrounding territories, and thus lacked jurisdiction. According to Yerevan, Nagorno-Karabakh is a sovereign state called "NKR." The European Court of Human Rights produced a definitive conclusion in that case: "Armenia thus exercised effective control over Nagorno-Karabakh and the surrounding territories."

“Azerbaijan justifiably responded to this ruling with calls for an immediate withdrawal of occupying forces. In fact, the ministry of foreign affairs of Azerbaijan published a statement, saying among other things: "Consequently, Armenia is under the obligation to withdraw immediately, completely and unconditionally its armed forces from these territories."

Murinson says: “Armenia's response in their official statements was to disparage and attempt to humiliate the European Court. Foreign Minister Edward Nalbandian said that "the negotiations on the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict settlement are not conducted within the framework, under the umbrella, or through the mediation of the European Court of Human Rights" and that "the Co-Chairmanship of the OSCE Minsk Group is the only internationally mandated format dealing with the resolution of the issue."

 

 

 



Views: 181
Latvian ambassador congratulates Azerbaijan on successful completion of COP29 Yesterday, 18:00 President Ilham Aliyev: Azerbaijan has created favorable conditions for lasting peace in the South Caucasus 22-11-2024, 18:30 “Missing Families of Karabakh” Public Union welcomes adoption of “Missing Persons” resolution by UN General Assembl 20-11-2024, 18:30 COP29 features panel discussion on “COP to COP Agrifood Legacies: A Key to Achieving Global Climate Goals” 19-11-2024, 20:30 Foreign Ministry comments on Fifth Opinion of Advisory Committee on Implementation of Council of Europe Framework Convention for Protection of National Minorities by Azerbaijan 18-11-2024, 19:30 World leaders hail Azerbaijan’s excellent organization of COP29 14-11-2024, 10:00 Senior Advisor to U.S. President: We have worked very hard with COP Presidency on a range of issues 11-11-2024, 21:00 Religious leaders express gratitude to President of Azerbaijan for organization of Global Baku Summit 6-11-2024, 22:07 President of Azerbaijan Ilham Aliyev arrived in Kyrgyzstan 5-11-2024, 19:00 US Foreign Policy Association: Swiss Peace Forum on Karabakh must be two-sided 4-11-2024, 20:30 Azerbaijan’s Foreign Ministry: France is not interested in sustainable and tangible peacebuilding in the region 31-10-2024, 19:00 Ambassador Cahit Bagci: We consider COP29 as a global event aimed to further reinforce Azerbaijan 30-10-2024, 19:00 President Ilham Aliyev: We are immensely proud that Azerbaijan-Türkiye relations are at their highest 29-10-2024, 17:30 President Ilham Aliyev met with Prime Minister of Armenia in Kazan 24-10-2024, 21:00 President Ilham Aliyev offers condolences to Turkish President over terrorist act 23-10-2024, 20:00 Conference on outcomes of French colonization kicks off in Geneva 22-10-2024, 20:00 Joseph Biden: The United States stands ready to support a durable and dignified peace between Azerbaijan and Armenia 21-10-2024, 19:30 3+3 ministerial meeting kicks off in Istanbul 18-10-2024, 19:30 Community: Attempts by circles ignorant of region to interfere in internal affairs of Azerbaijan are completely unacceptable 17-10-2024, 18:30 Azerbaijan`s Foreign Ministry: Persecution of Pavel Durov and Kemi Seba by France for their political views and convictions is unacceptable 16-10-2024, 19:30 Ombudsman: International community should speak out against Armenian mine terror 15-10-2024, 19:00 Azerbaijan extends arrest term for Armenian separatists Arayik Harutyunyan, David Babayan and others 11-10-2024, 19:00 Community: Publication of anti-Azerbaijani statements on the same day demonstrates that attacks on Azerbaijan are controlled from a single center 9-10-2024, 21:30 President Ilham Aliyev inspected construction progress at Zangilan Recreation Complex 3-10-2024, 21:00 Azerbaijani President: The tragedy of missing persons is one of the grave consequences of Armenia's aggression 2-10-2024, 20:00 President Ilham Aliyev attended the unveiling of Ashig Alasgar's statue in Baku 30-09-2024, 16:00 Coordination Headquarters convenes for meeting in Kalbajar 25-09-2024, 21:00 President Ilham Aliyev viewed “ADEX-2024" and "Securex Caspian" exhibitions 24-09-2024, 19:30 Postage stamp marking 530th anniversary of prominent Azerbaijani poet Mahammad Fuzuli issued in Germany 23-09-2024, 19:00 Hafiz Pashayev: Training modern era specialists in Azerbaijan is the need of the hour 10-09-2024, 11:00

Calendar
«    November 2024    »
MonTueWedThuFriSatSun
 123
45678910
11121314151617
18192021222324
252627282930